Crib Mattress Reviews 2017

Your baby needs all the love and care you can give. This includes providing them with a place where they can have a restful sleep. The best baby cribs guarantee the comfort and safety of your baby. A crib mattress should not only be tight-fitting, but also firm so that no space between the crib walls and mattress is wasted.

If you can fit two side-by-side fingers between the mattress and the baby crib, the mattress poses a safety risk as it is too small for the crib. You want to make sure that your little one will be comfortable and safe while sleeping. Reading crib mattress reviews can help you decide which option is best for your child. Here are some of the most important things to consider when choosing the best crib mattress for your baby.

Correct Fitting and Size

There should be only around two fingers of space between the mattress and the crib’s frame. A mattress that is too small or too big for the crib poses danger to your baby. Using a mattress that is larger than the crib makes it hard to change sheets. On the other hand, using a mattress that is smaller than the crib can result in suffocation or accidental entrapment when the baby wedges a leg or arm in between the crib’s frame and the beddings.

Breathable and Durable Covering

A properly ventilated mattress will not only allow better air circulation, but also smell fresher even after using it for several months. The covering should have small vent-like openings to prevent odor from accumulating. It should also be waterproof and durable. If the cover is waterproof, it has better resilience to wear and tear and soggy diapers. This will make it easier to clean the mattress.

Firmness Index

An extremely soft mattress can pose a hazard to your baby such as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome or accidental suffocation.  It is important to know if mattress has an above average rate of recovery. You can do this by applying considerable pressure on the mattress using your palm. The mattress should be able to regain its original shape after a few seconds.

Machine Washable

The mattress will be soiled often, so it will definitely help you save a lot of time if the exterior cover can be removed and machine washed. Machine washed fabric will also last longer than textiles washed by hand.

Firmness and Weight Balance

Reading crib mattress reviews may have given you an idea about the proper firmness and weight balance. A crib mattress that’s too heavy will make it hard for you to change sheets. Beddings usually need to be changed at least 1 or two every week. An extremely light or thin mattress is less durable and has a low rate of recovery. Anything between 7 pounds and 16.5 pounds should be convenient and comfortable for you and your little one. If you are choosing a baby crib mattress, you need to get a firm one as it a soft mattress will pose suffocation risks to your child. The thicker and firmer a mattress is, the safer it is for your baby.

Certified Padding

If you want to buy an organic mattress, you need to make sure that it meets the standards set by the Global Organic Textile Standards. It should bear a CPSC mark of quality and should be checked and certified by the American Society for Testing and Materials.

Cons of Crib Mattress

Aside from getting the best baby cribs, you also need to get the best mattress for your little one. A crib mattress is designed to support the body of your baby, helping in your child’s blood circulation and preventing them from developing spinal scoliosis. There are various kinds of crib mattress and each of them has their own share of pros and cons. Here are some of them.

Foam Crib Mattress

A foam crib mattress is lightweight and can be removed as well as folded with ease. It’s also available in various sizes. However, it is less durable compared to other types and is not suggested for long-term use.

Innerspring or Coil Spring Crib Mattress

A coil spring crib mattress is sturdy and can last for many years. It uses coiled steel, so it’s heavier than other crib mattresses. Poor quality coil spring mattress squeaks.

Organic Crib Mattress

An organic crib mattress is natural, breathable and free from chemicals. It can be quite expensive, so reading crib mattress reviews will certainly help you pick the best one for your child and budget.

Why Buy Crib Mattress at Amazon?

Amazon offers a large selection of the best baby cribs and baby crib mattresses to pick from. The online store also offers a 30-day return policy and free or prime shipping, so you can shop with peace of mind.

How to Buy Crib Mattress at Amazon

You only need to sign in to your account, browse through the list of products, add the best crib mattress you have chosen to your card and choose your preferred payment method. The product will be delivered to you within the specified date.


1.Colgate Classica I Lightweight Foam Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Colgate Classica I is a 5″ thick mattress with extra-firm foam that provides the necessary support for proper infant development and safety. Measuring 51.6″ x 27.2″ x 5″ and weighing 8 pounds, the Colgate Classica I has a triple-layered cover that is waterproof and tear-resistant, making it easy to clean with mild soap and wet cloth. The square corners of the mattress provide a snug crib it. Its cloth-binding also guarantee long-lasting seams. It is lightweight, so you won’t have any problem changing the sheets. The Colgate Classica I fits all standard-size American toddler beds and cribs. It is also certified by GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US to have no dangerous emissions. The high-quality mattress is manufactured in the US and meets the strict standards of Colgate. Some reviewers claimed that the mattress is very stiff. However, a stiff mattress is actually a good option as it will prevent any suffocation hazard.–>Check price at

2.My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam Infant Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam is an extremely firm high-density mattress that supports the growing bones of the child and keeps him safe and comfortable while sleeping. It may feel stiff to you, but your child will adjust to this mattress. Measuring 51-5/8″ x 27-1/4″ x 5″, this mattress comes with a waterproof cover that can be removed with ease. It is hypoallergenic and can be machine washed. Since it is waterproof, the chances of bacterial and mold growth are lower. My First Mattress Premium Memory Foam has square corners that guarantee a snug fit and is CeriPUR-US certified. It also comes with a ten-year warranty. It’s quite expensive, but the benefits are worth the price.–>Check price at

3.Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness EcoFriendlier Crib Mattress


->See more Images<–

Designed to provide the firmness needed by infants for proper development and support, The Colgate Eco Classica III is dual-firmness crib mattress filled with six-inch eco-friendly foam made with plant oils. The less firm side offers the comfort needed by toddlers while the extra firm area provides the firmness required by infants. It comes with an ultra-soft waterproof organic cotton cover. The inverted seams guarantee the durability of the mattress. Measuring 51.7″ x 27.5″ x 6″, the Colgate Eco Classica III is certified by GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US. It also complies with state and federal flammability requirements. This mattress is made in the US and weighs 9.4 pounds. Since it’s a thick mattress, you need stretchy fabric sheets for it.–>Check price at

4.Sealy Nature Couture Cotton Bliss 2 Stage InfantToddler Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

Weighing 18 pounds and measuring 27.2″ x 5.8″ x 51.6″, The Sealy Nature Couture Crib Mattress has an organic cotton cover that offers a silky feel and durability. It offers the patented Crypton Clean Sleep Technology that not only provides an allergen-barrier and water-resistant sleeping surface, but keeps the mattress soft, cool and quiet as well. You are assured that no fluids will stain or seep through the surface. You only need to use soap and water or Crypton clean solution to clean the cover. Aside from creating a durable foundation, the204-coil mattress also has extra support elements such as six EverEdge side and corner protectors and border wire. The softer side is ideal for toddlers while the infant side offers a firm surface for babies.–>Check price at

5.Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Safety 1st Transitions Mattress features 2 mattress pads. It features two firmness levels. One side supports infants while the other side supports toddlers. The mattress is resilient and lightweight. Its waterproof surface is PVC-free and can be cleaned with ease. Measuring 52″ x 27.5″ x 5.5 and weighing 8 pounds, the Safety 1st Transitions Mattress fits all standard toddler beds and cribs. The mattress is firm. According to some customers, the surface of the mattress feels like “paper” cloth, but adding a simple mattress protector solved the problem.–>Check price at

6.Newton Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Newton Crib Mattress is 100 percent breathable. It allows babies to breathe through the mattress, reducing any risk of suffocation. The mattress also offers better air circulation, which prevents overheating and sweaty backs. It doesn’t contain springs, allergens, foam or glue and can be machine washed, which prevents the growth of bacteria. One of the best things about the Newton Crib Mattress is that it can be recycled. Its core is made of 10 percent food-grade polymer and 90 percent free air. Measuring 28″ x 5.5″ x 52″ and weighing 11 pounds, the Newton Crib Mattress is wrapped up on a three-dimensional textile that unzips with ease. The only downside to this mattress is that although the core and cover are washable, you need to air dry the core. This can be a problem when your baby stays awake for several hours.–>Check price at

7.Sealy Baby Posturepedic Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

Featuring 220 Posturetech sensory coils, The Sealy Baby Crib Mattress provides maximum durability and posture support to your child. The entwined sensory coils move with your child and provide corrective support. It has a border wire that keeps the corners, edges and sides of the mattress firm. The anti-sag distribution system also evenly distributes the weight of your baby over the mattress. It has four extra support and comfort layers. The cover is improved with STAPH-GARD and waterproof to provide an antistatic and antibacterial surface. Measuring 27.25″ x 51.63″ x 5.75″ and weighing 14 pounds, this mattress comes with a lifetime warranty on materials and workmanship. One downside to this mattress is that the waterproof material can make the sheets slide. Putting a water-resistant mattress pad under the fitted sheet can help solve the problem.–>Check price at

8.Sealy Soybean FoamCore Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress a high density core that offers a firm but comfortable sleeping surface for babies. The extra cotton cushioning provides a stable sleeping environment for your child. It has a pearl embossed cover that is waterproof and can be wiped clean with a baby wipe or soap and water. The water-resistant binding also ensures that no liquids or stains will leak into the mattress. Measuring 52″ x 28″ x 5″ and weighing 8.3 pounds, the Sealy Soybean Crib Mattress fits USA standard toddler beds and cribs. The cover of this mattress is made of vinyle-laminate, the only of the mattress that’s not organic. However, Sealy stated that the cover is flammability and phthalate- compliant and doesn’t have any dangerous fire retardants.–>Check price at

9.Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Mattress


–>See more Images<–

One side of The Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Mattress offers an ideal firmness for babies while the other side provides a comfortable surface for toddlers. Weighing 26 pounds and measuring 52″ x 27.5″ x 6″, this mattress has a natural cotton wrap that meets federal flammability standards. 231 Pocketed Coil Springs provide even support and the Innofoam corner protectors as well as border protection offer added stability. The woven fabric cover is stain and water-resistant. It comes with a limited lifetime warranty.–>Check price at

10.Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

Measuring 27.5″ x 52″ x 6″ and weighing 6.8 pounds, The Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress is lightweight and easy to clean due to its waterproof surface. It doesn’t contain any harmful allergens or chemicals. Since it is lightweight, changing the sheets is easy. This mattress is also well-sealed and it has no smell or fumes. The waterproof cover, however, is easily punctured. You may want to take this factor into consideration.–>Check price at

11.Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 252 Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Naturepedic No Compromise Crib Mattress has a polyethylene water-resistant surface that is very easy to clean. It doesn’t contain wool, latex or other dangerous materials. Weighing 27 pounds and measuring 52″ x 27.8″ x 6″, the Naturepedic No Compromise Crib Mattress offers firm support for toddlers and babies. It meets the certification standards set by GREENGUARD. A mattress cover is needed, which is a separate investment you need to consider. –>Check price at

12.Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer


Measuring 53″ x 29″ x 7″ and weighing 10 pounds, The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer provides a very firm dual sided surface. One side offers a very firm high density surface for babies and the other side provides a firm high density surface for toddlers. The clean lines, 5-inch thick design and smooth design of this mattress make a beautiful bed for babies and toddlers. It’s also vinyl and PVC-free. This mattress, however, is quite expensive.

13.Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress


–>See more Images<–

The Naturepedic No Compromise 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress measures 6″ x 27.8″ x 52″ and weighs 20 pounds. It features 150 coils, seamless water-resistant edges and edge support. The waterproof surface is easy to clean and non-toxic. This mattress is ideal for parents who want to eliminate possibly dangerous allergens and chemicals that can harm the health of their child. It’s organic cotton throughout and meets the certification standards set by GREENGUARD. However, this mattress is expensive.–>Check price at

14.Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Lightweight Dual Firmness Crib Mattress


Weighing 10 pounds and measuring 6″ x 27.8″ x 52″, The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Lightweight Crib mattress has layers of organic cotton batting that offer the perfect balance of comfort and firmness. It provides the firmness needed by babies and the comfort required by toddlers. Changing the sheets is easy. The mattress is made from food-grade polyethylene and built with the wave support technology Naturepedic is known for, so you are assured that it’s safe. This mattress is quite expensive, but its benefits are worth it.

15.Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress


The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress has a polyethylene water-resistant surface that provides a solid barrier to dirt and dust mites. It doesn’t contain coir, latex or other harmful materials. This mattress provides firm support for babies and toddlers. It’s also easy to clean. Measuring 27.75″ x 52″ x 6″ and weighing 50 pounds, this mattress fits standard cribs and toddler beds. It’s quite heavy, but fits well.

Leave a Reply